| 1 | Paper | Clocks | A printed photo collage of your first year, framed |
| 2 | Cotton | China | A photo printed on a cotton pillow cover |
| 3 | Leather | Crystal or glass | A leather-bound album of your third year |
| 4 | Fruit or flowers | Appliances | A heart made of every bouquet and garden photo |
| 5 | Wood | Silverware | A collage mounted on a wood panel or in a wood frame |
| 6 | Iron (Hallmark and Blue Nile give “candy or iron”) | Wood | A “6” collage in an iron or black metal frame |
| 7 | Wool or copper | Desk sets | A small framed collage for a desk, in a copper frame |
| 8 | Bronze (Hallmark gives “pottery or bronze”) | Linen or lace | A linen-covered photo album of eight years |
| 9 | Pottery (Hallmark gives “willow or pottery”) | Leather | Photo-printed ceramic tiles or coasters |
| 10 | Tin or aluminum | Diamond jewelry | A “10” collage printed on aluminum (a metal print) |
| 11 | Steel | Fashion jewelry | A collage in a brushed steel frame |
| 12 | Silk or linen | Pearls | A favorite photo printed on a silk scarf |
| 13 | Lace | Textiles | A photo quilt or a printed throw |
| 14 | Ivory (Ivory is now usually replaced; Hallmark lists only gold jewelry) | Gold jewelry | A gold locket with two small photos |
| 15 | Crystal | Watches | A wedding photo engraved in a crystal block |
| 16 | Wax (Hallmark only) | Silverware | A candlelit dinner with sixteen years of photos on the table |
| 17 | Furniture (Hallmark only) | Furniture | A framed collage for the wall above a piece you chose together |
| 18 | Porcelain (Blue Nile gives “pottery” as the modern gift) | Porcelain | A porcelain plate printed with a photo |
| 19 | Bronze (Hallmark only) | Bronze | A sepia-toned collage in a bronze frame |
| 20 | China | Platinum | A china plate printed with your wedding photo |
| 21 |
No agreed gift. Hallmark’s theme: Fire | An evening by the fire with your photos printed small |
| 22 |
No agreed gift. Hallmark’s theme: Water | A collage of every beach, lake and river trip |
| 23 |
No agreed gift. Hallmark’s theme: Air | A collage of every trip you flew to |
| 24 |
No agreed gift. Hallmark’s theme: Stone | A photo printed on a slate stone |
| 25 | Silver | Silver | A “25” collage in a silver frame |
| 26 |
No agreed gift. Hallmark’s theme: Art | Your best photo as a gallery-wrapped canvas |
| 27 |
No agreed gift. Hallmark’s theme: Music | Concert and dance-floor photos with the lyrics of your song |
| 28 |
No agreed gift. Hallmark’s theme: Linens | Photos printed on pillowcases or a tea towel |
| 29 |
No agreed gift. Hallmark’s theme: Tools | A collage of everything you built and fixed together |
| 30 | Pearl | Diamond | A “30” collage with a pearl-white mat |
| 31 |
No agreed gift. Hallmark’s theme: Travel | A scrapbook page for every trip you took together |
| 32 |
No agreed gift. Hallmark’s theme: Bronze | A sepia collage of the early years in a bronze frame |
| 33 |
No agreed gift. Hallmark’s theme: Iron | A black metal photo stand with a rotating set of prints |
| 34 |
No agreed gift. Hallmark’s theme: Food | A family recipe book with a photo of each dish |
| 35 | Coral | Jade | A heart of 35 years of trips on a coral background |
| 36 |
No agreed gift. Hallmark’s theme: Antiques | Your wedding photos scanned and restored |
| 37 |
No agreed gift. Hallmark’s theme: Books | A photo book with one page for each year |
| 38 |
No agreed gift. Hallmark’s theme: Luck | A collage of your luckiest days |
| 39 |
No agreed gift. Hallmark’s theme: Laughter | Your funniest photos together as a “39” |
| 40 | Ruby | Ruby | A “40” collage on a ruby-red background |
| 41 |
No agreed gift. Hallmark’s theme: Office or desk decor | A small framed collage for each of your desks |
| 42 |
No agreed gift. Hallmark’s theme: Clocks or watches | A wall clock with a family photo face |
| 43 |
No agreed gift. Hallmark’s theme: Entertainment | A movie night with a slideshow of your years |
| 44 |
No agreed gift. Hallmark’s theme: Electronics | A digital frame loaded with every year |
| 45 | Sapphire | Sapphire | A collage on a deep blue background |
| 46 |
No agreed gift. Hallmark’s theme: Games | A jigsaw puzzle of your wedding photo |
| 47 |
No agreed gift. Hallmark’s theme: Garden or plants | A collage of your garden through the years |
| 48 |
No agreed gift. Hallmark’s theme: Home improvement | A collage of every home you have lived in |
| 49 |
No agreed gift. Hallmark’s theme: Copper | A collage in a copper frame |
| 50 | Gold | Gold | A “50” collage in a gold frame |
| 51 |
No agreed gift. Hallmark’s theme: Photos or cameras | Every family album scanned into one shared library |
| 52 |
No agreed gift. Hallmark’s theme: Bath or spa | A spa day and a framed photo from your honeymoon |
| 53 |
No agreed gift. Hallmark’s theme: Plastic | A favorite photo printed on acrylic |
| 54 |
No agreed gift. Hallmark’s theme: Glass | A favorite photo printed on glass |
| 55 | Emerald | Emerald | A collage on a deep green background |
| 56 |
No agreed gift. Hallmark’s theme: Day | One photo from every anniversary day, in order |
| 57 |
No agreed gift. Hallmark’s theme: Night | A collage of your evenings out |
| 58 |
No agreed gift. Hallmark’s theme: Faith and hope | A heart of the family you built |
| 59 |
No agreed gift. Hallmark’s theme: Charity | A donation in their name with a card of photos |
| 60 | Diamond | Diamond | A “60” collage printed large for the party |